Second Thoughts of Puzzle Piece

Digital media of primary sources and the ability to evaluate the use of words to tell a narrative allows students to dissect the narrative about specific events, like the final years before the 19th amendment. Digital media with the digitization of images, congressional records, and newspapers allows the student to evaluate the anti-suffrage movement and the choices of their words to fight the protests and lobbying efforts of the NAWSA and National Women’s Party. I plan to focus on the DMV area and the local efforts by anti-suffrage groups, specifically the publisher and the newsletter called “The Woman Patriot.”

The Woman Patriot newsletter continued after the 19th amendment passed. The arguments within this newsletter reveal propaganda associating suffragists with socialists, feminists, Bolsheviks, and pro-German during WWI. Allowing a side-by-side comparison of word usage like riots, pro-German, socialism, feminism, and militant from anti-suffrage to suffrage newsletters could allow word and topic modeling within the texts. This may shape my final project as word usage in newsletters, lobbying efforts, and protests could be compared. Both sides used the background of patriotic propaganda of World War I to further their cause. In the Woman Patriot, the outline of what they stood for clear. Women were to be the stewards of the home and not involved in politics. This was the best way to honor the men fighting in World War I. E By exploring the words used by the three main groups, DC anti-suffragists, NAWSA, and National Women’s party, the student can analyze how the World War I propaganda were part of these newsletters that have all been digitized. This shapes my final project pitch based on how students interpret these different primary sources and think about how the words used during World War I were employed by anti and suffragists alike. The digital programs to do text analysis of the documents of “The Woman Patriot” and newspapers could be run through voyant or Mallet for topic modeling only if I can teach myself quickly enough in time to see this data visually and if this helps teach students about how to look at the suffrage movement in context of anti-suffrage, especially in Washington, DC. Interestingly, there are quotes from Capital police when arresting suffrage demonstrators who talked about how they do not have the vote either since they live in DC. Just an interesting tidbit I ran across about suffragists being brought down to the level of a DC resident.

Realistically, for this class and the short amount of time, a more teaching type of exercise may include a museum type exhibit of images and several textual primary sources on the one event of burning Wilson’s speeches and how this was described based on anti-suffrage versus the competing suffragist groups. “The Woman Patriot” termed this event as a riot and other sources described this event as a protest, or militant protest and have the student evaluate the different primary sources to contextualize and form their own narrative about the event and if these events helped or hindered public opinion about women’s suffrage could be a good lesson plan.

Leave a Comment

css.php