History teaching has changed in the late 20th and 21st century with the digitization of primary sources and the free-flowing access to information on the internet. While this has improved students’ access to information, especially college students who can access paid databases that their respective college subscribes to, it does not necessarily teach how to do a good analysis of these sources. The importance of history teaching is the same as it was when Carl Becker’s addressed the American Historical Association and described that everyone is a historian.[1] At the heart of history teaching, is how to teach students to think critically about sources within the context of the time they are written. With the improved access to primary sources due to digital access, this teaching has become even more fundamental. If you agree with Carl Becker that everyone is a historian, then teaching history in this way will help everyone think more critically about their own past and the country they reside in.
Over the last twenty years, history teaching has attempted to evolve from coverage teaching of facts within textbooks, to teaching historical thinking about sources and narratives. A significant push for historical thinking is from SoTL, Standards of Teaching and Learning. “Early on, history SoTL specialists realized that one of the most important tasks in front of them was replacing the coverage model’s understanding of what it means to be proficient at history—which unintentionally reinforced public misperceptions of history as important things that happened—with new understandings of expertise based on how historians think and tuned to how people learn.”[2]History textbooks in the United States have overall been mass-produced by four major publishing companies and do not truly teach historical thinking. [3] External constraints on teachers by the few narratives in USA history textbooks can be alleviated by digital access to sources, alternative narratives that are made free for teachers and students, and continued dedication to encouraging the questioning of narratives. The AHA Tuning project is a way to assess teaching and learning about history that adopts technology and techniques to improve and measure historical thinking.[4]
Digital techniques for assessing primary sources through analysis using computer-generated programs like word analysis and networks within primary documents is just one example of 21st century learning that can help teachers escape the constraints of textbooks. Many digital humanities and websites also have learning plans and exhibits online that expand the narrative on events or people to help learners develop historical thinking skills. These new techniques for teaching history with a focus on digital content that can improve teacher skills for historical thinking allows a freedom of expression away from standard textbooks and are an adjunct to text and primary source analysis.
[1] Edward L. Ayers, Everyone Their Own Historian. Journal of American History Volume 105, Issue 3, December 2018, Pages 505–513, https://doi-org.mutex.gmu.edu/10.1093/jahist/jay276
[2] Lendol Calder and Tracy Steffes. “Measuring College Learning in History.” Social Science Research Council. May 2016.
[3] Hyde, Anne. AHA History Tuning Project: 2016 History Discipline Core. American Historical Association.
[4] Lindaman, Dana, and Kyle Roy Ward. Introduction History Lessons: How Textbooks from Around the World Portray U.S. History. New York: The New Press, 2004.